How To Make Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe That Tastes Like Fall In A Jar

Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe is one of those magical creations that brings warmth, flavor, and just the right amount of fun into your kitchen—and here at Kitchen Yumy, that’s exactly what we’re all about.

Hi, I’m Sophie, the heart behind Kitchen Yumy, where comfort food and crave-worthy recipes are served up with a big side of real life. This recipe isn’t just a seasonal sipper—it’s a family-tested, flavor-packed project I fell in love with during a chilly autumn weekend when I wanted to bottle up the taste of fall.

True to the Kitchen Yumy philosophy, this moonshine recipe is easy to follow, full of bold flavor, and perfect for sharing. Whether you’re a seasoned home cook or just now learning how to handle high-proof spirits, you’ll find this drink delightfully approachable. I’ve simplified the process, made room for customization, and packed in all the cinnamon-spiced coziness your fall cravings demand.

This one’s for cozy nights, festive gifts, and that unforgettable “Wow, did you really make this?” reaction when friends take their first sip.

So grab a pot, clear your counter, and let’s make some moonshine magic—Kitchen Yumy style.

Introduction to Apple Pie Moonshine

What Is Apple Pie Moonshine?

Apple pie moonshine is a sweet, spiced homemade liquor crafted with apple juice, apple cider, and high-proof alcohol like grain alcohol or vodka. Despite the name, this drink doesn’t contain traditional pie crust—it’s all about mimicking the warm, nostalgic flavors of a freshly baked apple pie.

Popular in Southern U.S. culture, moonshine itself refers to any unaged, homemade liquor. The “apple pie” version elevates it into something smooth, flavorful, and seasonally festive. It’s often sipped during the fall or winter, especially around holidays like Thanksgiving or Christmas.

And no, you don’t need distillery-level equipment. This apple pie moonshine recipe can be made right in your kitchen with ingredients from any grocery store.

Why This Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe Is a Fall Favorite

This recipe blends sweetness, spice, and strength all in one mason jar. It uses:

• Apple juice and cider for a rich, fruity base
• Brown and white sugar for layered sweetness
• Cinnamon sticks and apple pie spice for warm, familiar aromatics
• A mix of grain alcohol and vodka for that unforgettable kick

Apple pie moonshine is perfect for sipping chilled, gifting in jars, or mixing into warm cocktails. Its nostalgic flavor and long shelf life make it ideal for seasonal celebrations or cozy nights at home.

Plus, homemade versions are much more customizable than store-bought varieties. You can adjust the sweetness, increase the cinnamon, or even add in vanilla or caramel notes.

Ready to get started? Let’s dive into the ingredients next.

Table of Contents

Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe Ingredients Explained

Core Ingredients You’ll Need

Making a rich and flavorful apple pie moonshine recipe starts with the right ingredients. Let’s break down what you’ll need and why each one matters:

Ingredient	Quantity	Purpose
Apple Juice	1 gallon	Forms the fruity base of the moonshine
Apple Cider	1 gallon	Adds tartness and real apple flavor
White Sugar	2 cups	Balances the spice with sweetness
Brown Sugar	2 cups	Adds depth and a caramel note
Cinnamon Sticks	4 (or more to taste)	Infuses warm, spicy flavor
Apple Pie Spice	1 pinch	Enhances the baked apple taste
Grain Alcohol (190 proof)	750ml	Delivers the strong moonshine kick
Vodka	750ml	Softens the grain alcohol with smoothness

The pairing of apple cider and brown sugar creates a base that feels like autumn in a bottle. Adding both white and brown sugars gives your moonshine a layered sweetness—one crisp, one molasses-rich.

Meanwhile, cinnamon sticks and apple pie spice round out the drink with that unmistakable apple pie essence.

The Role of Grain Alcohol and Vodka in Flavor and Strength

Grain alcohol is what gives moonshine its legendary potency. At 190 proof, it’s highly concentrated—so just a little goes a long way. But don’t worry, when blended properly with the cider mixture, it mellows into a smooth, warming sip.

Vodka, on the other hand, adds volume and alcohol content without overpowering the flavor. It also helps balance the sharpness of the grain alcohol. The result? A potent yet drinkable concoction that’s perfect for sipping or mixing.

Tips:

• Always measure carefully. Too much grain alcohol can overpower your flavor balance.
• Avoid using flavored vodkas—they can clash with the spices and natural apple profile.

This recipe is perfect for first-timers or seasoned home brewers alike. In the next section, we’ll walk through the exact steps to bring your ingredients together.

Print

Step-by-Step Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe

Prepping Your Apple Base

The base of your apple pie moonshine is what delivers the warm, spiced flavor everyone loves. Before you start, make sure your ingredients are measured out and your containers are sanitized.

Here’s how to begin:

1. In a large stock pot, combine:
   • 1 gallon of apple juice
   • 1 gallon of apple cider
   • 2 cups white sugar
   • 2 cups brown sugar
   • 4 cinnamon sticks (or more if you love that extra kick)
   • A pinch of apple pie spice
2. Stir the mixture thoroughly until all the sugars dissolve.
3. Bring it to just below a boil over medium-high heat. This step activates the spices and blends the flavors.
4. Once near boiling, reduce the heat to low and cover the pot.
5. Simmer gently for about 1 hour, allowing all ingredients to meld into a syrupy, apple-infused base.

Your kitchen will start to smell like a fresh-baked apple pie—seriously.

Cooking, Simmering, and Cooling Process

Now here’s the key: patience.

Let the mixture cool completely before adding alcohol. This is non-negotiable. If the mixture is even warm, it could evaporate some of the alcohol, dulling the potency of your finished moonshine.

After cooling:

1. Remove the cinnamon sticks. You can leave them in if you prefer stronger spice notes, but over time they can become bitter.
2. Slowly stir in:
   • One 750ml bottle of 190-proof grain alcohol
   • One 750ml bottle of vodka
3. Mix thoroughly and use a ladle or funnel to pour the moonshine into clean, airtight glass jars or bottles.
4. Store them in the refrigerator to let flavors mellow over time. The longer it sits, the smoother it gets.

Tips for Success:

• Use wide-mouth mason jars—they’re easier to fill and clean.
• Label the jars with the bottling date.
• Store in a cool, dark place if you’re not refrigerating immediately.

You’ve now made a legit batch of homemade apple pie moonshine. In the next section, we’ll talk about how to store it safely and make it last.

Storing Your Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe Safely

How to Bottle and Seal Properly

Once your apple pie moonshine recipe is complete and cooled, proper storage is essential to preserve flavor and extend shelf life. The type of container you use can affect both the taste and longevity.

Best practices for bottling:

• Use glass jars or bottles: Mason jars with airtight lids are perfect. Avoid plastic containers—they can leach unwanted flavors over time.
• Sterilize your containers: Boil your jars and lids or run them through a dishwasher on a sanitize cycle before use.
• Use a funnel: This keeps the process clean and avoids spills, especially when handling a sticky syrup-alcohol blend.

Once sealed, store your moonshine in a cool, dark place. The fridge is ideal, especially after opening, but unopened jars can sit in a dark pantry if the seal is tight.

Refrigeration and Shelf Life Tips

Here’s where many first-time moonshiners ask: Do I need to refrigerate it?

Short answer: Yes, once opened.

Unopened, high-proof apple pie moonshine can last up to 2 years if kept sealed and stored away from direct sunlight. The alcohol content acts as a preservative. But once a jar is opened:

• Refrigerate immediately
• Use within 3 to 4 months for best flavor and safety
• Keep away from direct heat or fluctuating temperatures

If your moonshine starts to taste flat or overly sweet, it might be time to brew a fresh batch.

Storage Recap Table:

Storage Type	Opened	Unopened
Pantry	Not recommended	Up to 2 years
Refrigerator	3–4 months	Up to 1 year (ideal)
Freezer	Avoid (alcohol may separate)	Not advised

Next, we’ll look at how your apple pie moonshine transforms over time and how long you should wait before drinking it.

Flavor Development Over Time

Does Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe Get Stronger?

Yes—and not just in taste. One of the most exciting things about a homemade apple pie moonshine recipe is how it evolves with time.

While the alcohol content itself remains stable (it doesn’t increase), the perceived strength can intensify as the sugars and spices meld more thoroughly with the alcohol. This makes each sip smoother yet more robust in flavor.

Here’s why:

• The grain alcohol continues to extract oils and flavors from the cinnamon and spice, making the overall profile bolder.
• The acidity from the cider softens, reducing harsh notes.
• Sugar binds more evenly, balancing sweet and heat.

Ideal rest period: Let it sit for 2 to 3 weeks before drinking. Some enthusiasts even wait 4 weeks for the best result.

How Long Should You Let It Sit Before Drinking?

While it’s technically ready to drink as soon as it’s chilled, giving it time to “age” allows it to taste more like a professionally crafted liqueur.

Rest Time	Flavor Profile
24 hours	Harsh, raw alcohol taste
3–5 days	Mildly blended, still sharp
2 weeks	Smooth, spicy, and mellow
1 month	Fully matured with deep flavor harmony

Just like wine or fine whiskey, a bit of patience pays off. The sugars and spices integrate fully, and the overall balance becomes richer, smoother, and far more enjoyable.

Planning to gift your moonshine? Make it a month ahead, then bottle and label it for maximum flavor and presentation value.

Up next, we’ll dive into how to enjoy and mix your apple pie moonshine in fun, creative ways.

Mixing and Serving Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe

What to Mix with Sugarlands Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe

Already crafted your homemade version or grabbed a bottle of Sugarlands apple pie moonshine from the store? Either way, this moonshine is more versatile than you might think.

Here are some delicious mixers that balance its warm spice and fruity kick:

Mixer	Flavor Profile	Ratio Suggestion
Ginger beer	Spicy + bubbly	1:1
Cream soda	Smooth + sweet	1 part moonshine to 2 parts soda
Apple cider	Classic + cozy	Equal parts
Lemonade	Tart + refreshing	1 part moonshine, 3 parts lemonade
Vanilla cream soda	Dessert-style	1:2 for a pie à la mode twist

Pro Tip: Add a cinnamon stick to your glass for a visual and aromatic boost.

Tasty Cocktails You Can Create

Homemade apple pie moonshine doesn’t just belong in a jar—it shines in cocktails too.

1. Moonshine Mule

• 2 oz apple pie moonshine
• 4 oz ginger beer
• Splash of lime
  Serve in a copper mug over ice.

2. Spiked Apple Cider Float

• 1 scoop vanilla ice cream
• 1 oz apple pie moonshine
• Top with chilled cider
  Tastes like dessert in a glass.

3. Cinnamon Apple Martini

• 2 oz apple pie moonshine
• 1 oz vanilla vodka
• Dash of cinnamon sugar on rim
  Shake with ice and strain into a chilled glass.

4. Harvest Sangria

• 1 bottle white wine
• 1 cup apple pie moonshine
• Sliced apples, pears, and oranges
• Splash of sparkling water
  Let sit in the fridge for 2–3 hours to infuse.

5. Hot Apple Pie Toddy (Winter Classic)

• Heat 1 cup apple cider
• Add 1.5 oz moonshine
• Garnish with cinnamon stick and orange peel

Whether you’re throwing a party or sipping solo by the fire, these ideas bring cozy flavor to every glass. And since moonshine is so potent, a little goes a long way—perfect for slow sipping.

Next, we’ll troubleshoot common issues—like cloudy jars or unexpected flavors—so your batch stays smooth and safe.

Troubleshooting and FAQs

Why Is My Apple Pie Moonshine Recipe Cloudy?

One of the most common concerns when making an apple pie moonshine recipe is cloudiness. While a slightly hazy look can be normal due to the apple cider and spices, excessive cloudiness may signal a few avoidable issues:

Top reasons your moonshine looks cloudy:

1. Insufficient cooling before adding alcohol
   • If you added grain alcohol or vodka before the mixture was completely cool, it can cause separation or haze.
2. Unfiltered spices or residue
   • Ground spices or small bits of cinnamon stick left in the jar may cause particles to float and cloud the jar.
3. Storage temperature fluctuation
   • Storing in a warm place or inconsistent refrigeration can lead to sediment shift and haze formation.
4. Using unfiltered cider or juice
   • Organic or unfiltered liquids naturally contain pulp and particles, which can cloud over time.

Fix it:

• Strain your mixture using cheesecloth before bottling.
• Always store in the fridge after opening.

Cloudy doesn’t always mean unsafe, but it can affect taste and shelf life.

Other Common Questions Answered

Does Apple Pie Moonshine Get Stronger the Longer It Sits?

No, it doesn’t gain alcohol content. But it tastes stronger because flavors mature and alcohol integrates more smoothly over time. Letting it rest for 2–4 weeks enhances balance and boldness.

Does Apple Pie Moonshine Need to Be Refrigerated After Opening?

Yes. Once opened, your jars should be refrigerated to prevent fermentation and preserve taste. The high alcohol content protects it from spoiling, but refrigeration ensures freshness.

What to Mix With Sugarlands Apple Pie Moonshine?

You can mix it with ginger beer, cider, cream soda, or lemonade. Try it in a hot toddy or make a festive sangria for holiday gatherings.

Why Is My Moonshine Too Sweet or Too Harsh?

If it’s overly sweet, you may have added too much sugar or reduced the simmering time. If it’s too harsh, let it sit longer so the alcohol mellows out.

Next, let’s look at the safety side of making and enjoying your batch responsibly.

Safety Tips and Alcohol Awareness

Grain Alcohol Safety and Responsible Use

Let’s be honest—moonshine is no joke when it comes to potency. The standard apple pie moonshine recipe contains 190-proof grain alcohol, which is 95% ABV. That’s nearly double the strength of most liquors.

Here’s how to stay safe when making and consuming:

• Never drink it undiluted – Always mix moonshine with juice, soda, or other mixers.
• Label your jars clearly – Indicate proof level, batch date, and ingredients (especially if gifting).
• Keep away from heat or open flame – Grain alcohol is flammable. Store in a cool, dry place away from stoves or candles.
• Store out of reach of children and pets – Treat it like you would any high-proof spirit.
• Don’t serve to underage guests – Even if it’s homemade, all alcohol laws still apply.

If you’re gifting your moonshine, include clear “For Adults Only – Alcoholic Beverage” tags on every jar.

How to Safely Share Your Moonshine With Friends

Sharing your moonshine is half the fun—but make it smart and safe:

1. Use sealed mason jars – These make the perfect shareable container and limit spills.
2. Include instructions – Note if it should be chilled before drinking and remind people of its strength.
3. Start small – Pour 1 to 2 oz servings so people can ease into it.
4. Offer food with drinks – Moonshine on an empty stomach? Not a good idea.

And if you’re serving at a party, be the responsible host. Make sure guests have transportation or a place to stay if needed.

Moonshine is meant to be enjoyed in moderation and with mindfulness—because nobody remembers that night they almost overdid it, right?

Next up, let’s get creative with flavors, bottling ideas, and gifts.

Creative Variations and Gift Ideas

Fun Flavor Twists: Caramel, Vanilla, or Spicy

While the classic apple pie moonshine recipe is a standout on its own, adding custom flavors can make your batch even more unique—and memorable.

Here are some flavorful add-ins to elevate your next batch:

Add-In	Flavor Effect	When to Add
Vanilla bean or extract	Smooth, creamy dessert-like finish	Add during simmer
Caramel syrup	Sweet and buttery richness	Add after cooling before alcohol
Cloves or nutmeg	Deeper spice, more holiday warmth	Simmer with cinnamon
Chili flakes	Sweet heat for adventurous sippers	Add to individual jars only
Maple syrup	Earthy, smoky sweetness	Add before alcohol for best mix

Tip: Don’t go overboard—start small with flavoring and test by the jar if unsure.

Bottling as Gifts: Labels, Presentation, and Customization Ideas

Apple pie moonshine makes a fantastic DIY holiday or party gift, especially when bottled with care.

How to gift like a pro:

• Use mason jars, swing-top bottles, or decorative glass containers.
• Create custom labels using printable sticker paper. Include name, batch date, ingredients, and fun instructions like “Serve chilled” or “Mix with ginger ale.”
• Add twine, ribbon, or gift tags with a mini cinnamon stick for rustic charm.
• Attach recipe cards with serving ideas or cocktail suggestions.

Holiday Tip: Bottle your moonshine 2–4 weeks before gifting. This ensures it’s flavorful, mellow, and ready to impress.

Gift Occasion	Bottle Size Suggestion	Personalization Ideas
Holiday party	16 oz	Red ribbon & cinnamon stick
Wedding favor	8 oz mini jars	Custom tags with couple’s name
Housewarming	32 oz	Label with cocktail recipe
Father’s Day	750ml bottle	Add bourbon or smoked spice twist

Homemade moonshine shows effort, creativity, and charm. When done right, it’s not just a drink—it’s an experience in a jar.

Now let’s tie everything together in the conclusion and finalize the FAQ section you provided.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does apple pie moonshine get stronger the longer it sits?

While the alcohol content doesn’t increase, the flavor becomes stronger over time. Letting your moonshine rest for 2 to 4 weeks allows the alcohol, spices, and sugars to meld, resulting in a smoother and more potent-tasting drink.

Does apple pie moonshine need to be refrigerated after opening?

Yes. After opening, store it in the refrigerator to maintain freshness and prevent spoilage. The cold helps preserve flavor and reduces the risk of fermentation or cloudiness.

What to mix with Sugarlands apple pie moonshine?

Great mixers include ginger beer, cream soda, apple cider, or lemonade. Try it in cocktails like a Moonshine Mule or a spiked hot toddy for delicious results.

Why is my apple pie moonshine cloudy?

Cloudiness can come from warm alcohol addition, unfiltered juice, or leftover spice particles. To avoid this, cool your mixture fully before adding alcohol and strain through cheesecloth before bottling.

Conclusion

Crafting your own apple pie moonshine recipe is more than just making a drink—it’s about creating an experience. From choosing the right mix of cider and spices to customizing flavors and gifting it beautifully, every jar holds the warmth of home and holiday spirit.

With just a few ingredients, some patience, and the right safety steps, you can create a bold, nostalgic beverage that’s perfect for sipping, sharing, and celebrating.

Whether you’re new to moonshine or a seasoned DIY enthusiast, this guide offers all the tools you need to get it right, every single time.

Fore more recipes follow me on facebook and pinterest